RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8561-8572 ================================= THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED REPORT. SOME INFORMATION MAY DIFFER FROM THE HISTORICAL REPORT. THE ASSESSMENT SENT TO THE PUBLIC FORUM IS THE DEFINITIVE SOURCE OF HISTORICAL INFORMATION. The official historical report is located at https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2021-June/014992.html ID Title Result -------------------------------------------------- 8561 Election Cycle ADOPTED 8562 Officializing Discord ADOPTED 8563 Determinacy is a Good Thing REJECTED 8564 Sponsorship is not Co-authorship ADOPTED 8565 Popularity Contest ADOPTED 8566 Anti-AI escalation ADOPTED 8567 AI voting method clarification REJECTED 8568 Supporter/Objector clarification REJECTED 8569 Fixing Festivals ADOPTED 8570 Emergency Regulation Clarification ADOPTED 8571 Gauntlet announcement patch ADOPTED 8572 Thou shalt not disobey Trigon ADOPTED I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals. The quorum for all below decisions was 3. The following sponsored adopted proposals have the highest popularity (0.900): 8566 (by Janet), 8570 (by Janet), 8572 (by Janet). VOTING STRENGTHS ================ Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted. *: player has voting strength 8 <: player has voting strength 13 PROPOSALS ========= PROPOSAL 8561 (Election Cycle) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (7): ATMunn, Falsifian, G.*, Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, cuddlybanana AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Aris<, Murphy, Trigon BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 26/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8562 (Officializing Discord) AUTHOR: ATMunn CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (8): ATMunn, G., Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, Murphy, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (1): Falsifian PRESENT (1): Aris BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 24/3 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8563 (Determinacy is a Good Thing) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (3): Aris, Madrid, cuddlybanana AGAINST (7): ATMunn, Falsifian, G., Gaelan, Janet, Murphy, Trigon PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 9/21 (AI=1.7) POPULARITY: -0.400 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8564 (Sponsorship is not Co-authorship) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (7): ATMunn, Aris<, Falsifian, Gaelan, Madrid, Murphy, cuddlybanana AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): G.*, Janet, Trigon BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 31/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8565 (Popularity Contest) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (8): ATMunn, Aris<, G.*, Janet, Madrid, Murphy, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (2): Falsifian, Gaelan PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 39/6 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.600 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ G.: Endorsement of Murphy ] PROPOSAL 8566 (Anti-AI escalation) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (9): ATMunn, Aris, Falsifian, Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, Murphy, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): G. BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 27/0 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.900 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of Janet Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet Trigon: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8567 (AI voting method clarification) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (4): ATMunn, Madrid, Murphy, cuddlybanana AGAINST (4): Aris, Falsifian, Janet, Trigon PRESENT (2): G., Gaelan BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 12/12 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.000 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Aris: Endorsement of Janet Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet Trigon: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8568 (Supporter/Objector clarification) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (5): ATMunn, Aris, Madrid, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (3): Falsifian, Gaelan, Janet PRESENT (2): G., Murphy BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 15/9 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8569 (Fixing Festivals) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (8): ATMunn, Falsifian, Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, Murphy, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (1): Aris PRESENT (1): G. BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 24/3 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of Janet Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet Trigon: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8570 (Emergency Regulation Clarification) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (9): ATMunn, Aris, Falsifian, Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, Murphy, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): G. BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 27/0 (AI=3.1) POPULARITY: 0.900 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8571 (Gauntlet announcement patch) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (7): Aris<, Falsifian, Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): ATMunn, G.*, Murphy BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 31/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8572 (Thou shalt not disobey Trigon) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (9): ATMunn, Aris<, Falsifian, Gaelan, Janet, Madrid, Murphy, Trigon, cuddlybanana AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): G.* BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 37/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.900 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet ] The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8561 Title: Election Cycle Adoption index: 2.0 Author: G. Co-authors: nix Create a power=2 rule, "The Election Cycle", with the following text: A holder of an elected office who did not become its holder by winning an election, and has not won an election for that office since, is an interim holder. An elected office that is either vacant or has an interim holder is an interim office. An office is term-limited if the most recent election for that office was resolved more than the length of that office's term prior. The term for the office of Prime Minister is 90 days. The term for all other elected offices is 180 days. A player CAN initiate an election for a specified elected office: a) with 2 support, if either the office is interim or term- limited, and provided that the initiator becomes a candidate in the same message. b) By announcement, if e is the ADoP (or, if the office is the ADoP, if e is the Assessor) and the office is interim, or if e is the holder of that office. Once per quarter, the ADoP CAN and SHALL publish a Notice of Election specifying between 2-4 term-limited offices (if there fewer than 2 term-limited offices, the ADoP MUST instead list all of them). Such a notice initiates elections for the specified offices. The ADoP SHOULD prioritize offices that have gone longest since their last elections. The above notwithstanding, an election for an office CANNOT be initiated if one is already in progress. [Delete this section added to the previous rule - better gathers election procedure rules in one place]. Amend Rule 1006 (Offices) by removing: A holder of an elected office who did not become its holder by winning an election, and has not won an election for that office since, is an interim holder. An elected office that is either vacant or has an interim holder is an interim office. [For the below rule, remove text placed in the new rule above, and add the Assessor as the vote collector for ADoP elections]. Amend Rule 2154 (Election Procedure) to read in full: When an election is initiated, it enters the nomination period, which lasts for 4 days. After an election is initiated and until nominations close, any player CAN become a candidate by announcement. A candidate ceases to be a candidate if e ceases to be a player during the election or if holding the office would make em Overpowered. During the nomination period, a candidate CAN cease to be a candidate by announcement if there is at least one other candidate. An election whose nomination period is complete is contested if it has two or more candidates, and uncontested otherwise. Nominations close at the end of the poll's voting period or when the election is ended, whichever comes first. After the nomination period ends, the ADoP (or, if the office is the ADoP, the Assessor) CAN and, in a timely fashion, SHALL: 1) If the election is contested, initiate an Agoran decision to select the winner of the election (the poll). For this decision, the Vote Collector is the ADoP (or, if the office is the ADoP, the Assessor), the valid options are the candidates for that election (including those who become candidates after its initiation), and the voting method is instant runoff. When the poll is resolved, its outcome, if a player, wins the election. If the outcome is not a player, the election ends with no winner. 2) If POSSIBLE per the following paragraph, end the election immediately. If at any point an uncontested election has a single candidate, then any player CAN by announcement declare em the winner of the election, thereby causing em to win the election. If at any point an uncontested election has no candidates, then any player CAN declare the election ended with no winner by announcement. When a player wins an election, e is installed into the associated office and the election ends. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8562 Title: Officializing Discord Adoption index: 3.0 Author: ATMunn Co-authors: Aris The Publicity switch of the Discord server having the ID of 724077429412331560 and being accessible from the permanent invite link of https://discord.gg/tz2u6m7 is hereby flipped to Discussion. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8564 Title: Sponsorship is not Co-authorship Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Aris Co-authors: [It's always felt weird to me that pending a proposal now makes you a co-author. That's not what co-authorship means, IMO. Also, it goes against my mental invariant that proposals are immutable after creation.] Amend rule 2622, "Pending Proposals", by deleting the text: If the player did not create the proposal and is not listed in the list of co-authors of the proposal, e is added to the list of co-authors. [For context, here's the current text of the paragraph: Any player CAN pay 1 Pendant to flip the Pended switch of a specified proposal to True. If the player did not create the proposal and is not listed in the list of co-authors of the proposal, e is added to the list of co-authors. When e does so, the proposal becomes sponsored.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8565 Title: Popularity Contest Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Aris Co-authors: Enact a new power 1.0 Rule entitled "Popularity Contest", with the following text: Immediately after the adoption of this rule, Aris wins the game. Then, for each person who voted unconditionally FOR the referendum on the proposal that enacted this rule, this rule causes that person to earn a Black Ribbon. Aris CAN cause this rule to make a specified player earn a Black Ribbon by announcement. Aris can cause this rule to award a specified player a specified patent title containing the string "Popular" by announcement. If it has been at least one month since this rule was adopted, any person CAN End the Contest by announcement, causing this rule to repeal itself. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8566 Title: Anti-AI escalation Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend rule 1950 by appending the following to the first paragraph: " If a referendum has an adoption index less than the adoption index of its associated proposal, the referendum's adoption index is immediately set to that of the associated proposal". [Prevents a potential 2->3 power escalation where a Power 2 dictatorship can set the AI of the referendum on an AI 3 proposal to 1, then force it through at AI 1.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8569 Title: Fixing Festivals Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Aris, Murphy Amend Rule 2124 by replacing the following text: { The entities eligible to support or object to an intent to perform an action are, by default, all players, subject to modification by the document authorizing the dependent action. } with the following text: { A document that authorizes a dependent action, by default, implicitly asserts that all players are eligible to support or object to an intent to perform that action; if the document is a rule, conflicts about eligibility (including conflicts with such an implicit assertion) are resolved using the normal procedures. } Set the power of Rule 2480 (Festivals) to 3.1. Set the power of Rule 2481 (Festival Restrictions) to 3.1. Amend Rule 2481 (Festival Restrictions) by replacing "Non-Festive players are never considered Supporters of a dependent action" with "Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, non-Festive players are not eligible to support a dependent action". [Currently, eligibility to object/support to a dependent action is defined wholly by the rule defining the action. This breaks the festival rule that non-festive players are not considered supporters. This proposal changes the definition of eligibility so that it uses the normal precedence rules, then raises the power of Festivals so that it applies to the highest-power dependent action (emergency regulation changes).] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8570 Title: Emergency Regulation Clarification Adoption index: 3.1 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 2614 by replacing "Award Patent Titles not mentioned in any Rule and Badges" with "Award Patent Titles that are either Badges or are not mentioned in any Rule". [Just a minor wording tweak, this has always looked weird to me.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8571 Title: Gauntlet announcement patch Adoption index: 2.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 2644 (The Gauntlet) to read, in whole: { A player CAN, by announcement, Notice the Gauntlet, specifying a single player that owns 5 or more stones. When e does, the specified player Wields the Gauntlet. When a player Wields the Gauntlet, e wins the game, then all existing stones are transferred to Agora. } [This removes the possibility of accidentally causing someone to Wield the Gauntlet by changing the "correct announcement" to a specific action. For instance, I am concerned that a Stonemason's weekly report might be considered such an announcement.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8572 Title: Thou shalt not disobey Trigon Adoption index: 2.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Trigon Amend Rule 2545 by appending the following to the paragraph beginning "When the rules authorize": "Persons who voluntarily participate in an auction (including the auctioneer) SHALL NOT violate requirements that auction's method that are clearly intended to be punishable as rules violations; doing so is the Class N Crime of Auction Manipulation, where N is the class specified in the auction method (or 2 otherwise)." //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////