RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8442-8457 ================================= THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED REPORT. SOME INFORMATION MAY DIFFER FROM THE HISTORICAL REPORT. THE ASSESSMENT SENT TO THE PUBLIC FORUM IS THE DEFINITIVE SOURCE OF HISTORICAL INFORMATION. The official historical report is located at https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2020-June/013879.html ID Title Result -------------------------------------------------- 8442 Barrel Barrel Badger Barrel ADOPTED 8443 Term Limit REJECTED 8444 Sedate Officiation REJECTED 8445 Easier Retitling ADOPTED 8446 Victory Auctions ADOPTED 8447 Rule Infancy REJECTED 8448 Populist Administration ADOPTED 8449 Simpler Heraldry ADOPTED 8450 CFJ extensions ADOPTED 8451 HUMBLE AGORAN FARMER WINS THE GAME REJECTED 8452 Indictment Fixes ADOPTED 8453 win indirection ADOPTED 8454 Judicial non-person fixes ADOPTED 8455 old judgements are good judgements ADOPTED 8456 namings REJECTED 8457 CHILL BRO REJECTED I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals. The quorum for all below decisions was 8. VOTING STRENGTHS ================ Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted. $: player has voting strength 4 %: player has voting strength 5 ^: player has voting strength 6 &: player has voting strength 7 *: player has voting strength 8 PROPOSALS ========= PROPOSAL 8442 (Barrel Barrel Badger Barrel) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: ECONOMY FOR (7): ATMunn%, G.^, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, nix% AGAINST (1): R. Lee PRESENT (2): Falsifian, Trigon& BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 28/3 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.600 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of G. Kate: Endorsement of G. nix: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8443 (Term Limit) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: EFFICIENCY FOR (1): Murphy AGAINST (6): ATMunn, Falsifian%, Janet%, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, R. Lee, Trigon PRESENT (3): G.^, Kate, nix% BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 3/22 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: -0.500 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8444 (Sedate Officiation) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: EFFICIENCY FOR (0): AGAINST (7): ATMunn, G.^, Kate, Murphy, R. Lee, Trigon, nix% PRESENT (3): Falsifian%, Janet%, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 0/26 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: -0.700 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Kate: Endorsement of G. Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable ] PROPOSAL 8445 (Easier Retitling) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (8): ATMunn, G.$, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, Trigon, nix AGAINST (1): R. Lee PRESENT (1): Falsifian BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 25/3 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8446 (Victory Auctions) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: ECONOMY FOR (10): ATMunn%, Falsifian, G.^, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, R. Lee, Trigon&, nix% AGAINST (0): PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 41/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 1.000 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8447 (Rule Infancy) AUTHOR: Madrid CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (0): AGAINST (9): ATMunn, G.^, Janet%, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus&, R. Lee, Trigon, nix& PRESENT (1): Falsifian BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 0/40 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.900 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8448 (Populist Administration) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (5): Janet, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, Trigon, nix AGAINST (1): R. Lee PRESENT (4): ATMunn, Falsifian, G.$, Kate BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 15/3 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.400 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Falsifian: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8449 (Simpler Heraldry) AUTHOR: Aris CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (5): Janet%, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus&, Trigon, nix& AGAINST (4): Falsifian, G.^, Kate, R. Lee PRESENT (1): ATMunn BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 25/15 (AI=1.5) POPULARITY: 0.100 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Kate: Endorsement of G. nix: Conditional resolved: 8448 passed ] PROPOSAL 8450 (CFJ extensions) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: JUSTICE FOR (8): ATMunn, Falsifian, G.*, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus%, nix% AGAINST (1): R. Lee PRESENT (1): Trigon BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 33/3 (AI=1.7) POPULARITY: 0.700 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8451 (HUMBLE AGORAN FARMER WINS THE GAME) AUTHOR: Madrid CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (1): Trigon AGAINST (7): ATMunn, Falsifian, Janet%, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus&, R. Lee, nix& PRESENT (2): G.^, Kate BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 3/31 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.600 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8452 (Indictment Fixes) AUTHOR: Publius Scribonius Scholasticus CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: JUSTICE FOR (10): ATMunn, Falsifian, G.*, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus%, R. Lee, Trigon, nix% AGAINST (0): PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 39/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 1.000 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Falsifian: Endorsement of Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Kate: Endorsement of G. nix: Endorsement of Publius Scribonius Scholasticus ] PROPOSAL 8453 (win indirection) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (8): Falsifian, G.^, Janet%, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus&, R. Lee, nix& AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): ATMunn, Trigon BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 37/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.800 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8454 (Judicial non-person fixes) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: JUSTICE FOR (8): ATMunn, Falsifian, G.*, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus%, R. Lee AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): Trigon, nix% BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 31/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.800 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8455 (old judgements are good judgements) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: JUSTICE FOR (9): ATMunn, Falsifian, G.*, Janet, Kate, Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus%, R. Lee, nix% AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): Trigon BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 36/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.900 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8456 (namings) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: PARTICIPATION FOR (3): ATMunn, Janet%, Trigon AGAINST (3): Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus&, R. Lee PRESENT (4): Falsifian, G.^, Kate, nix& BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 11/13 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.000 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Kate: Endorsement of G. nix: Conditional resolved: G. not FOR: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8457 (CHILL BRO) AUTHOR: R. Lee CLASS: ORDINARY CHAMBER: EFFICIENCY FOR (3): Murphy, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus, R. Lee AGAINST (5): ATMunn, G.^, Kate, Trigon, nix% PRESENT (2): Falsifian%, Janet% BALLOTS: 10 AI (F/A): 9/20 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: -0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Janet: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Kate: Endorsement of G. ] The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8442 Title: Barrel Barrel Badger Barrel Adoption index: 1.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Create a power-1 rule, "The General Store", with the following text: Barrels are a currency tracked by the Coopor (an office) in eir monthly report. A player CAN Corner the Market by paying a fee of 100 barrels. When a player corners the market, e wins the game. A bargain is a specification consisting of a title, a payout (a number of barrels between 1 and 10), and a tender (a list of 6 or more rules-defined card types; a type may be repeated, with each repeat being a separate element on the list). A player CAN cash out a specified bargain that's "on the barrel", by announcement, provided that, in the same message, e paid cards (possibly spread over multiple sets) to successfully earn rules- defined products, and those cards match all of the cards types in that bargain's tender. The payment of a particular card instance can only match a single tender element for the single cashing out of a bargain. When a player cashes out a bargain on the barrel, e earns the payout for that bargain. The Coopor CANNOT cash out a specific bargain in the 14 days after putting that bargain on the barrel. Create a power-1 rule, "Bargains on the Barrel", with the following text: If there are fewer than four bargains on the barrel, the Coopor CAN put a bargain on the barrel with notice. If there are fewer than eight bargains on the barrel, the Coopor CAN put a bargain on the barrel with 3 support. The Coopor CAN take a bargain off the barrel without N objections, where N is the number of months, rounded up, since that bargain was last placed on the barrel. Within 14 days after winning an election for Coopor, the Coopor CAN take any bargain off the barrel with notice. The Coopor's monthly report includes a list of all bargains on the barrel. E SHOULD publish such a list whenever e adds or removes a bargain from the barrel. There are no bargains on the barrel. G. is hereby made Coopor. An election for Coopor is hereby initiated. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8445 Title: Easier Retitling Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Aris Co-authors: [It's been bothering me for years that it takes a full proposal to fix an incorrect title. This would simplify that in obvious cases, and is pretty safe given that titles are non-substantive (while this could interfere with a proposal, cleanings can already do that.)] Amend Rule 2221, "Cleanliness", by adding as a new paragraph: Any player CAN refile a rule without objection, specifying a new title; the rule is retitled to the specified title by this rule. Retitle Rule 2221 to "Cleanliness and Tidy Filing" ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8446 Title: Victory Auctions Adoption index: 1.0 Author: G. Co-authors: nix If Proposal 8407 (no stinking auction definitions) has not taken effect, the rest of this proposal has no effect. Enact the following rule, Victory Auctions: The Treasuror CAN conduct an auction (a "victory auction") if no victory auction is ongoing. The Treasuror MUST do so at least once a month, and SHOULD do so at least twice each month. A victory auction includes the following lots: * one new Victory Card. * all of any single type of card or product, currently owned by the Lost and Found Department, if any. The currency of a victory auction is coins (minimum bid 1). ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8448 Title: Populist Administration Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Aris Co-authors: Alexis, Falsifian If a proposal titled "The Administrative State" has been adopted in the last month, the remainder of this proposal has no effect. Enact a new power 2.0 rule entitled "The Administrative State", with the following text: Each officer CAN, with 1.5 Agoran consent, enact, amend, or repeal eir own office's Administrative Regulations. Administrative Regulations have the following properties: 1. An officer SHALL abide by eir office's administrative regulations in the discharge of eir office. 2. Any player CAN act on behalf of an officer to exercise eir official powers as authorized by eir office's administrative regulations. 3. All players SHOULD abide by an officer's administrative regulations in matters relating to eir area of responsibility. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8449 Title: Simpler Heraldry Adoption index: 1.5 Author: Aris Co-authors: Alexis, Janet, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Amend Rule 649, "Patent Titles", by appending to the last paragraph: Any player CAN award a specified Patent Title to a specified player, as authorized by the Herald's Administrative Regulations. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8450 Title: CFJ extensions Adoption index: 1.7 Author: G. Co-authors: Amend Rule 591 (Delivering Judgements) by appending the following paragraph: If the judge of an open CFJ has not violated a time limit for assigning it a judgement, and has not previously filed a motion to either extend or reconsider the case, e CAN file a motion to extend the case by announcement. Doing so extends eir judgement deadline for that case by one week. In doing so, e SHOULD include a (nonbinding) draft or outline of eir current thoughts on the case. [Self-filed motions to reconsider have been used a handful of times for the above. Might as well make it official, removes the Arbitor's guesswork on when to reassign a late case. Policy statement: the flip side is that, as Arbitor I'd be more strict on reassignment deadlines for people who are late without requesting the extension]. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8452 Title: Indictment Fixes Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Co-authors: Janet, Trigon Amend Rule 2619, "Indictment" by inserting "CAN and" prior to "SHALL initiate". Amend Rule 2619, "Indictment" by inserting ", by announcement," following "the investigator CAN". Amend Rule 2619, "Indictment" by appending the following sentence as a new paragraph: "If it would be ILLEGAL or INEFFECTIVE for the Investigator to levy a fine for the stated crime, all decisions associated with the Indictment cease to exist, and the Judge and Investigator are freed of any obligations of this rule." ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8453 Title: win indirection Adoption index: 1.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Amend Rule 2553 (Win by Paradox) by replacing: that case's initiator CAN, by announcement, win the game. with: that case's initiator, CAN, by announcement, Transcend Logic. When a person transcends logic, e wins the game. [This should make all wins in the rules indirect: Ribbons, Tournaments, and Apathy are indirect already] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8454 Title: Judicial non-person fixes Adoption index: 2.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Janet, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Amend Rule 991 (Calls for Judgement) by replacing: When a CFJ's judge is unassigned, the Arbitor CAN assign any eligible player to be its judge by announcement, and SHALL do so in a timely fashion. with: When an open CFJ's judge is unassigned, the Arbitor CAN assign any eligible player to be its judge by announcement, and SHALL do so in a timely fashion after it becomes an open and unassigned CFJ. and by replacing: Judge is an untracked CFJ switch with possible values of any person or "unassigned" (default). with: Judge is an untracked CFJ switch with possible values of any person or former person, or "unassigned" (default). Every CFJ that had a former person as a judge immediately before Proposal 8134 took effect (02 Dec 2018) hereby has their judge switch flipped to that judge. [I'm really, really sure there's been no changes or attempted changes to former persons' judgeship since Dec 2018, since all those cases were long before that and I'd remember that]. If G. received any blots in the past two months as the result of failure to assign a judge in a timely manner to any CFJ whose judge has been changed by this proposal, that number of blots are expunged from em. [Don't mind about 1 blot, this is mainly protection against "infinite" blotting if it happens] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8455 Title: old judgements are good judgements Adoption index: 2.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Janet, Publius Scribonius Scholasticus Amend Rule 991 (Calls for Judgement) by replacing: At any time, each CFJ is either open (default), suspended, or assigned exactly one judgement. with: At any time, each CFJ is either open (default), suspended, or assigned exactly one judgement that was validly assigned. [Jason pointed out a while ago, that you could argue that when a judgement option ceased to be defined (like UNDETERMINED has), it ceased to be a judgement, so the case reverted to open. Not sure if that's true, but this makes sure the "validity when assigned" is what matters]. //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////