RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 9049-9051
=================================

THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED REPORT.
SOME INFORMATION MAY DIFFER FROM THE HISTORICAL REPORT.
THE ASSESSMENT SENT TO THE PUBLIC FORUM IS THE DEFINITIVE SOURCE OF HISTORICAL INFORMATION.

The official historical report is located at https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2024-January/017579.html

ID    Title                          Result 
--------------------------------------------
9049  Registration restrictions      ADOPTED
9050  Self-ratification limitations  ADOPTED
9051  A Mossy Cabinet                ADOPTED

I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals.

The quorum for all below decisions was 5.

VOTING STRENGTHS
================

Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted.
#: player has voting strength 3
$: player has voting strength 4
%: player has voting strength 5
^: player has voting strength 6

PROPOSALS
=========

PROPOSAL 9049 (Registration restrictions)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (3): Janet, Murphy, ais523
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (2): juan, snail
BALLOTS: 5
AI (F/A): 9/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.600
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Janet: Endorsement of ais523
]

PROPOSAL 9050 (Self-ratification limitations)
AUTHOR: Janet
CLASS: DEMOCRATIC
FOR (3): Janet, Murphy, ais523
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (2): juan, snail
BALLOTS: 5
AI (F/A): 9/0 (AI=3.0)
POPULARITY: 0.600
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Janet: Endorsement of ais523
]

PROPOSAL 9051 (A Mossy Cabinet)
AUTHOR: snail
CLASS: ORDINARY
FOR (1): snail^
AGAINST (0): 
PRESENT (4): Janet^, Murphy%, ais523%, juan$
BALLOTS: 5
AI (F/A): 6/0 (AI=2.0)
POPULARITY: 0.200
OUTCOME: ADOPTED
[
Murphy: Janet is the Stonemason: Endorsement of Janet
]

The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below:

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9049
Title: Registration restrictions
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Janet
Co-authors: Aris, ais523


Amend Rule 869 by, as a single amendment (in order):

* Replacing the text "No person can be a player if e is part of another
player or another player is part of em." with "Rules to the contrary
notwithstanding, two or more persons CANNOT become Registered
simultaneously.".

* Inserting the following paragraph after the paragraph beginning "An
Unregistered person CAN":

{

The basis of a person is the set of all persons that are (recursively)
part of em, in addition to emself. Rules to the contrary
notwithstanding, a person CANNOT become Registered if eir basis overlaps
with that of any current player.

}


[

This fixes a bug where two group persons [A B] and [B C] could be both
be players, since neither is a part of the other.

In order to let this work, this also prohibits simultaneous
registrations. This is done now because simultaneous registrations would
break the check for overlapping persons (if [A B] and [B C] could
register simultaneously, neither would overlap with any existing player,
even if they overlapped with each other). As a more general matter,
simultaneous registrations seem likely to result in bugs, and
registration order has been used as a tiebreak before (e.g. for Spaaace).

]

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9050
Title: Self-ratification limitations
Adoption index: 3.0
Author: Janet
Co-authors: 


Amend Rule 2201 ("Self-Ratification") by, as a single amendment (in order):

* Replacing "When a public document is continuously undoubted for one
week after publication" with "When a public document published less than
180 days ago is first continuously undoubted for one week after publication"

* Replacing the text "identifying a document and explaining" with
"identifying a public document published less than 180 days ago and
explaining".

[First, prevent self-ratifying documents from ratifying more than once
if they go from undoubted to doubted to undoubted. Next, add a
(generous) time limit on self-ratification and doubts to prevent very
old documents from surprisingly being ratified or imposing a requirement
on their publishers to respond. Also, only allow claims of error on
published documents (which later parts of the rule assume anyway).]


Amend Rule 2201 ("Self-Ratification") by, as a single amendment (in order):

* Inserting the following paragraph before the paragraph beginning "Any
person CAN": "The definition of documents as self-ratifying and the
definition of documents as self-ratifying attestations are secured at
power 3."

* Appending the following paragraph to the Rule:

{

The issuance of a doubt on a documents, the denial of a claim of error,
and the ceasing of a doubt on a document to be a doubt are secured at
power 3.

}

[Prevent low-power dictatorships from making random things
self-ratifying and from automatically making or denying claims of error.
All self-ratifying things (assets, Proposal Pool, switches, Festivity,
decision initiation/termination) are already defined at power >= 3.]

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ID: 9051
Title: A Mossy Cabinet
Adoption index: 2.0
Author: snail
Co-authors: 


Amend Rule 2451 (Executive Orders) by appending the following Cabinet Order:

{
      - Growth (Stonemason): The Prime Minister increases the mossiness of
a specified stone by 2.
}

//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////