RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8700-8716 ================================= THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED REPORT. SOME INFORMATION MAY DIFFER FROM THE HISTORICAL REPORT. THE ASSESSMENT SENT TO THE PUBLIC FORUM IS THE DEFINITIVE SOURCE OF HISTORICAL INFORMATION. The official historical report is located at https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2022-July/016147.html ID Title Result ------------------------------------------------- 8700 Well, it's not doing anything. REJECTED 8701 Welp, that doesn't do anything REJECTED 8702 Writing on the Blank Stone REJECTED 8703 Ticking Stone REJECTED 8704 Tasty Stone ADOPTED 8705 Fixing Unfortunate Timing REJECTED 8706 Let them have points ADOPTED 8707 No, we really mean it REJECTED 8708 Has Beens ADOPTED 8709 Promises Any vs Each REJECTED 8710 Tabled action clarification ADOPTED 8711 Tabled action condition ambiguity REJECTED 8712 Stacking Stones v1.1 REJECTED 8713 Pebble Throwing REJECTED 8714 Vote scoring clarification ADOPTED 8715 Proposal protection REJECTED 8716 Dream of Wandering REJECTED I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals. The quorum for all below decisions was 5. PROPOSALS ========= PROPOSAL 8700 (Well, it's not doing anything.) AUTHOR: 4st CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (1): 4st AGAINST (3): G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (1): Murphy BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 3/9 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: -0.400 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ ais523: Conditional resolved: Proposal 8700 would be resolved as AGAINST if ais523 voted AGAINST with half strength ] PROPOSAL 8701 (Welp, that doesn't do anything) AUTHOR: 4st CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (1): 4st AGAINST (2): G., Janet PRESENT (2): Murphy, ais523 BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 3/6 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: -0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8702 (Writing on the Blank Stone) AUTHOR: 4st CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (2): 4st, Murphy AGAINST (3): G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 6/9 (AI=2.1) POPULARITY: -0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8703 (Ticking Stone) AUTHOR: 4st CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (3): 4st, Murphy, ais523 AGAINST (2): G., Janet PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 9/6 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8704 (Tasty Stone) AUTHOR: 4st CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (2): 4st, Murphy AGAINST (1): G. PRESENT (2): Janet, ais523 BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 6/3 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.200 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8705 (Fixing Unfortunate Timing) AUTHOR: snail CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (1): Murphy AGAINST (4): 4st, G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 3/12 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.600 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8706 (Let them have points) AUTHOR: snail CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (3): 4st, Murphy, ais523 AGAINST (1): G. PRESENT (1): Janet BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 9/3 (AI=1.5) POPULARITY: 0.400 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8707 (No, we really mean it) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (2): 4st, Murphy AGAINST (3): G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 6/9 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8708 (Has Beens) AUTHOR: nix CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (4): 4st, Janet, Murphy, ais523 AGAINST (1): G. PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 12/3 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.600 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8709 (Promises Any vs Each) AUTHOR: snail CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (3): Janet, Murphy, ais523 AGAINST (2): 4st, G. PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 9/6 (AI=2.2) POPULARITY: 0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8710 (Tabled action clarification) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (4): 4st, Janet, Murphy, ais523 AGAINST (1): G. PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 12/3 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.600 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8711 (Tabled action condition ambiguity) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (3): Janet, Murphy, ais523 AGAINST (2): 4st, G. PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 9/6 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8712 (Stacking Stones v1.1) AUTHOR: snail CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (1): Murphy AGAINST (3): G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (1): 4st BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 3/9 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.400 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8713 (Pebble Throwing) AUTHOR: snail CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (2): 4st, Murphy AGAINST (3): G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 6/9 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.200 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ ais523: Conditional resolved: Proposal 8712 has not been enacted (as of end of voting period) ] PROPOSAL 8714 (Vote scoring clarification) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (3): 4st, Janet, Murphy AGAINST (1): G. PRESENT (1): ais523 BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 9/3 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.400 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8715 (Proposal protection) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (1): Murphy AGAINST (4): 4st, G., Janet, ais523 PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 3/12 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.600 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8716 (Dream of Wandering) AUTHOR: 4st CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (2): 4st, Murphy AGAINST (2): G., Janet PRESENT (1): ais523 BALLOTS: 5 AI (F/A): 6/6 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.000 OUTCOME: REJECTED The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8704 Title: Tasty Stone Adoption index: 2.0 Author: 4st Co-authors: Amend the rule "The Stones" by adding another paragraph: "- Tasty Stone (Monthly, 70%): A specified bird that is owned by a player is transferred to the wielder." Then, create the Tasty Stone under the ownership of Agora. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8706 Title: Let them have points Adoption index: 1.5 Author: snail Co-authors: Amend Rule 2656 "Points" by replacing "wins the game via such an announcement, all players' scores are set to their default." with "wins the game via such an announcement, the scores of the winning players are set to their default, and then all other players' scores are set to half their current value rounded down." ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8708 Title: Has Beens Adoption index: 3.0 Author: nix Co-authors: snail, G., Madrid, 4st, Janet Amend R103 by replacing: If the office of Speaker has been held continuously by the same person for 90+ days, then any player CAN appoint another player to the office with support. with: If the office of Speaker has been held continuously by the same person for the past 90+ days, then any player CAN appoint another player to the office with support. Amend 2438 by replacing: White (W): A player qualifies for a White Ribbon if e has never previously owned a White Ribbon (including under previous rulesets). A player who has been registered for at least 30 days and has never acted on eir own behalf to cause another person to gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN act on eir own behalf to award a White Ribbon to another person by announcement. with: White (W): A player qualifies for a White Ribbon if e has never previously owned a White Ribbon (including under previous rulesets). A player who has been registered for the past 30+ days or 180+ cumulative days and has never acted on eir own behalf to cause another person to gain a White Ribbon (including under a previous ruleset) CAN act on eir own behalf to award a White Ribbon to another person by announcement. G. is the speaker. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8710 Title: Tabled action clarification Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: snail Amend Rule 1728 ("Tabled Actions") by replacing "An action is a Tabled Action if it is performed with one of the following methods" with "An action is a Tabled Action if the Rules purport to authorize its performance via one of the following methods". ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8714 Title: Vote scoring clarification Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 2657 (Scoring) by replacing the list item beginning "Casting" with the following: { * Having a valid unconditional AGAINST vote on a referendum when it is resolved to be ADOPTED, or, similarly, FOR when REJECTED: 1 (Assessor). } [Clarify that the referendum is resolved, rather than the proposal, that the vote must be valid, and that the condition is evaluated at the time of resolution.] //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////