RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8607-8629 ================================= THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED REPORT. SOME INFORMATION MAY DIFFER FROM THE HISTORICAL REPORT. THE ASSESSMENT SENT TO THE PUBLIC FORUM IS THE DEFINITIVE SOURCE OF HISTORICAL INFORMATION. The official historical report is located at https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2021-October/015418.html ID Title Result ----------------------------------------------------------- 8607 Asset Self-Ratification Fix ADOPTED 8608 Powering Up REJECTED 8609 Axiom of Limitations ADOPTED 8610 No Immediate Shenanigans ADOPTED 8611 Reasonably Responsive Reactivation REJECTED 8612 Tournament Conclusion Fixes v2 ADOPTED 8613 The Name of the Win Cards v2 ADOPTED 8614 Simultaneity Security ADOPTED 8615 Supporter/Objector clarification v2 ADOPTED 8616 Narrowing Margins REJECTED 8617 Forgiveness ADOPTED 8618 Solo Acitivity ADOPTED 8619 The Bottomless Pit REJECTED 8620 Im cool REJECTED 8621 Proposal spreading ADOPTED 8622 Allow acting on behalf to support or object REJECTED 8623 No prizeless victory auctions ADOPTED 8624 I'd like to thank the academy REJECTED 8625 giving the gift of an amendment REJECTED 8626 pledge(2)(2) REJECTED 8627 INSANITY CLAUSES REJECTED 8628 tacking into the win ADOPTED 8629 Independence Day ADOPTED I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals. The quorum for all below decisions was 5. The following sponsored adopted proposals have the highest popularity (1.000): 8609 (by Janet). VOTING STRENGTHS ================ Strength is 0 unless otherwise noted. -: player has voting strength 15 PROPOSALS ========= PROPOSAL 8607 (Asset Self-Ratification Fix) AUTHOR: Telna CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (12): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): Gaelan- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 165/0 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.923 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Telna ] PROPOSAL 8608 (Powering Up) AUTHOR: Telna CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (8): ATMunn-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Telna-, Trigon-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (5): Falsifian-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, ais523-, nix- PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 120/60 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.231 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Gaelan: Jason is the Rulekeepor: Conditional resolved: Jason and G. both voted FOR nix: Endorsement of ais523 ] PROPOSAL 8609 (Axiom of Limitations) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (13): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (0): PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 180/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 1.000 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8610 (No Immediate Shenanigans) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (10): ATMunn-, G.-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Falsifian-, Gaelan-, Telna- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 135/0 (AI=1.7) POPULARITY: 0.769 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8611 (Reasonably Responsive Reactivation) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (6): ATMunn-, Gaelan-, Madrid-, Shy Owl, Trigon-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (5): Falsifian-, G.-, Janet-, Murphy-, nix- PRESENT (2): Telna-, ais523- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 75/75 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.077 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8612 (Tournament Conclusion Fixes v2) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (9): ATMunn-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Telna-, Trigon-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (1): Falsifian- PRESENT (3): Murphy-, Shy Owl, ais523- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 135/15 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.615 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8613 (The Name of the Win Cards v2) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (9): ATMunn-, G.-, Janet-, Madrid-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (2): Falsifian-, ais523- PRESENT (2): Gaelan-, Murphy- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 120/30 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.538 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8614 (Simultaneity Security) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (11): ATMunn-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): Falsifian-, nix- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 150/0 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.846 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Trigon: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8615 (Supporter/Objector clarification v2) AUTHOR: Janet CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (7): ATMunn-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, ais523-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (3): Falsifian-, Shy Owl, nix- PRESENT (3): Murphy-, Telna-, Trigon- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 105/30 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.308 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Gaelan: Conditional resolved: Independence Day will be adopted ] PROPOSAL 8616 (Narrowing Margins) AUTHOR: nix CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (4): Madrid-, Trigon-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (6): Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Telna-, ais523- PRESENT (3): ATMunn-, Murphy-, Shy Owl BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 60/90 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.154 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8617 (Forgiveness) AUTHOR: nix CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (9): ATMunn-, G.-, Janet-, Madrid-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (1): ais523- PRESENT (3): Falsifian-, Gaelan-, Murphy- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 120/15 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.615 OUTCOME: ADOPTED PROPOSAL 8618 (Solo Acitivity) AUTHOR: nix CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (12): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (1): Shy Owl PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 180/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.846 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of nix ] PROPOSAL 8619 (The Bottomless Pit) AUTHOR: ATMunn CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (5): Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (6): Falsifian-, G.-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523- PRESENT (2): ATMunn-, nix- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 75/75 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.077 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8620 (Im cool) AUTHOR: R. Lee CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (3): Madrid-, Murphy-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (9): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523- PRESENT (1): nix- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 45/120 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.462 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Gaelan: Conditional resolved: proposal would not pass if AGAINST ais523: Conditional resolved: it is not true that the proposal would be adopted regardless of vote ] PROPOSAL 8621 (Proposal spreading) AUTHOR: R. Lee CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (5): Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (1): Janet- PRESENT (7): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 60/15 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.308 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ ATMunn: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable G.: Aris is the Promotor: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Gaelan: Aris is the Promotor: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable Janet: Aris would have been endorsed, but eir vote was inextricable Telna: Aris is the Promotor: Endorsement of non-voter Aris: Inextricable ] PROPOSAL 8622 (Allow acting on behalf to support or object) AUTHOR: R. Lee CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (4): Gaelan-, Madrid-, Shy Owl, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (7): Falsifian-, G.-, Janet-, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, nix- PRESENT (2): ATMunn-, Murphy- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 45/105 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.231 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Gaelan: Conditional resolved: Independence Day will be adopted ] PROPOSAL 8623 (No prizeless victory auctions) AUTHOR: Trigon CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (12): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): Telna- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 165/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.923 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Trigon ] PROPOSAL 8624 (I'd like to thank the academy) AUTHOR: Trigon CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (7): ATMunn-, Madrid-, Murphy-, Shy Owl, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (6): Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Telna-, nix- PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 90/90 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.077 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ G.: nix is the Herald: Endorsement of nix Janet: Endorsement of nix ] PROPOSAL 8625 (giving the gift of an amendment) AUTHOR: Trigon CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (4): Madrid-, Shy Owl, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (8): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523- PRESENT (1): Murphy- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 45/120 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.308 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8626 (pledge(2)(2)) AUTHOR: Trigon CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (4): Madrid-, Shy Owl, Trigon-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (8): Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Murphy-, Telna-, ais523-, nix- PRESENT (1): ATMunn- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 45/120 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.308 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Janet: Endorsement of G. nix: Conditional resolved: G. and Aris do not have equivalent votes because Aris did not vote ] PROPOSAL 8627 (INSANITY CLAUSES) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (4): ATMunn-, G.-, Madrid-, cuddlybanana- AGAINST (8): Falsifian-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Murphy-, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, nix- PRESENT (1): Shy Owl BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 60/120 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.308 OUTCOME: REJECTED PROPOSAL 8628 (tacking into the win) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: ORDINARY FOR (11): ATMunn-, Falsifian-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): Murphy-, ais523- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 150/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.846 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Gaelan: Trigon is the Treasuror: Endorsement of Trigon ] PROPOSAL 8629 (Independence Day) AUTHOR: G. CLASS: DEMOCRATIC FOR (11): ATMunn-, G.-, Gaelan-, Janet-, Madrid-, Shy Owl, Telna-, Trigon-, ais523-, cuddlybanana-, nix- AGAINST (1): Falsifian- PRESENT (1): Murphy- BALLOTS: 13 AI (F/A): 150/15 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.769 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ G.: Endorsement of ais523 Janet: Endorsement of G. ] The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8607 Title: Asset Self-Ratification Fix Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Telna Co-authors: ais523, Alexis In Rule 2166 "Assets", replace the text "This portion of that entity's report is self-ratifying." with the following: A public document purporting to be this portion of that entity's report is self-ratifying. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8609 Title: Axiom of Limitations Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 2553 by, as a single amendment, replacing "CAN, by announcement, Transcend Logic," with "CAN, by announcement, Transcend Logic, specifying that CFJ," and replacing "for at least 7 days" with "for between 7 and 90 days". [Requires that people Transcending Logic specify which case they are claiming the win for, ensuring that the "with respect to that CFJ" clause actually functions. Also adds a time limit to claim to prevent shenanigans and limit the scope of any bugs.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8610 Title: No Immediate Shenanigans Adoption index: 1.7 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 2478 by appending the following to the paragraph beginning "Initiating a Finger pointing found to be Shenanigans is ILLEGAL": "The investigator of a finger pointing SHALL NOT point eir finger for the Crime of Unjustified Gesticulation with respect to that finger pointing.". [Prohibits the Referee from ruling Shenanigans, then immediately pointing eir finger at the first pointer in order to get ahead on the finger pointing contest.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8612 Title: Tournament Conclusion Fixes v2 Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: G., Oerjan Amend Rule 2464, Tournaments, by replacing: { If a winner of a tournament is determined within within 3 months of its initiation, that person or persons win the game, otherwise the tournament concludes with no winner. } with: { Each time that one or more winners of a tournament are determined before it concludes, that person or those persons win the game. A tournament concludes when its regulations state that it concludes. Additionally, if it has not previously concluded, a tournament concludes 3 months after its initiation. } All ongoing tournaments hereby conclude with no (further) winner, except for the tournament initiated on or about 2 July 2021 (if it is still ongoing). [Ensures that any previous ongoing tournaments that found a winner are concluded (which the rule did not explicitly state).] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8613 Title: The Name of the Win Cards v2 Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Trigon In ascending numerical order, amend each enacted rule by case-insensitively replacing, as a single amendment per Rule: * "Victory Card" with "Win Card" * "Victory Point" with "Winsome" * "Extra Vote" with "Votive" Win Card balances are hereby set to what Victory Card balances were at the time immediately before this proposal began taking effect. Winsome balances are hereby set to what Victory Point balances were at the time immediately before this proposal began taking effect. Votive balances are hereby set to what Extra Vote balances were at the time immediately before this proposal began taking effect. [This introduces more whimsy into the asset names and means that Voting Card and Victory Card are no longer both VCs.] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8614 Title: Simultaneity Security Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 478 by, as a single amendment, inserting a paragraph break before "Any action performed by sending a message", then appending to the (new) final paragraph: "Allowing actions performed by sending a message to take place simultaneously must be done explicitly and is secured at power 2." [This prohibits simultaneity without an authorizing rule, which is less extreme than a total ban (which G. has exposed disapproval of).] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8615 Title: Supporter/Objector clarification v2 Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Amend Rule 2124 by replacing the following: { The above notwithstanding, if an action is to be performed without N objections or with N Agoran consent, and an objection to an intent to perform it has been withdrawn within the past 24 hours, then Agora is not Satisfied with that intent. The above notwithstanding, Agora is not satisfied with an intent if the Speaker has objected to it in the last 48 hours. A person CANNOT support or object to an announcement of intent before the intent is announced, or after e has withdrawn the same type of response. } with the following: { The above notwithstanding, if an action is to be performed without N objections or with N Agoran consent, and an entity has ceased to be an Objector to that intent within the past 24 hours, then Agora is not Satisfied with that intent. The above notwithstanding, Agora is not Satisfied with an intent if the Speaker has become an Objector to it in the last 48 hours. An entity is not considered a Supporter or Objector to an intent solely due to a purported support or objection made before the intent was announced. An entity is not considered a Supporter to an intent if e has previously ceased to be a Supporter to it, and e is not considered an Objector to an intent if e has previously ceased to be an Objector to it. } [ In each paragraph, use Objector/Supportor status instead of evaluating whether objections were withdrawn. For instance, it has been previously pointed out (in private conversation) that the Speaker could potentially completely block an intent by objecting multiple times. Additionally, in the third paragraph, extend the restrictions to entities instead of just persons (since the definition of Supporter/Objector applies to entities, rather than persons). Fixes the bug in the previous version where ever withdrawing an objection would prevent you from ever objecting again. ] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8617 Title: Forgiveness Adoption index: 1.0 Author: nix Co-authors: G. Agora formally forgives all fugitives listed on the most recent scroll of Agora. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8618 Title: Solo Acitivity Adoption index: 1.0 Author: nix Co-authors: Janet Amend R2646, "Activity" by by replacing: A player CAN activate or deactivate emself by announcement. with: A player CAN, acting as emself, activate or deactivate emself by announcement. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8621 Title: Proposal spreading Adoption index: 3.0 Author: R. Lee Co-authors: At the end of paragraph four of the rule 1607 "Distribution", append the following sentence "If there are ten or more pending undistributed proposals in the proposal pool, the promotor MAY refrain from distributing the most recently added 5 proposals if e distributes each other pending proposal in that Agoran week. E SHALL then distribute those undistributed proposals the next Agoran week. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8623 Title: No prizeless victory auctions Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Trigon Co-authors: [ COMMENT: After the reset, the poor player who still has the highest claim might be forced to pay for nothing; or, more realistically, the auction runner might just not be able to distribute lots for the auction. Either way, this is certainly not an ideal situation. ] In Rule 2561 "VP Wins" replace the following: Four days after such a win occurs, all Cards and all Products are destroyed. with: Four days after such a win occurs, all Cards and all Products are destroyed and any ongoing victory auctions end with no victors. All victory auctions that were initiated before this proposal was created end with no victors. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8628 Title: tacking into the win Adoption index: 2.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Amend Rule 2638 (Player Focuses) by replacing: At the beginning of a month, every active player's Ministry Focus is set to the value e mostly recently specified by Planning to Flip. If a player did not Plan to Flip eir Ministry Focus switch in the last month, it is not flipped. with: When the rules state that the winds change, every active player's Ministry Focus is set to the value e mostly recently specified by Planning to Flip. If a player did not Plan to Flip eir Ministry Focus switch since the last time the winds changed, it is not flipped. The winds change at the beginning of each month. Amend Rule 2621 (VP Wins) by replacing: Then, each active player gains 1 card of each type and eir grant (if any). with: Then, the winds change, following which each active player gains 1 card of each type and eir grant (if any). ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8629 Title: Independence Day Adoption index: 3.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Gaelan, Telna, nix, Madrid, cuddlybanana, Janet [Note: this proposal was not rushed, it was originally part of survivor golf, and then substantially honed on discord. Doesn't mean it should be thoroughly checked! Also, please see the note at the bottom.] Amend Rule 1728 (Dependent Action Methods) by changing its title to "Tabled Actions" and amending its text to: An action is a Tabled Action if it is performed with one of the following methods: * With N Support, where N is a positive integer. * Without N Objections, where N is a positive integer. * With N Agoran Consent, where N is a positive integer multiple of 0.1. * With T notice, where T is a time period. The parameters N and T, if omitted, default to 1 and 4 days, respectively (e.g. "without objection" means N=1). If a rule defines N as less than 1 or greater than 8, it is instead treated as 1 or 8, respectively. A person CAN act on eir own behalf, by announcement, to table an intent (syn. "intend") to perform a tabled action, conspicuously and without obfuscation specifying the action, the method (including non- default parameter values), and optionally, conditions. A person is the sponsor of such an intent if e tabled it, or if e is authorized to perform its action due to holding a rule-defined position previously held by the person who tabled it. Amend Rule 2124 (Agoran Satisfaction) by changing its title to "Performing Tabled Actions" and amending its text to: For a given tabled intent, a player CAN, unless otherwise forbidden by the rules or the document enabling the action, act on eir own behalf, by announcement, to: * Become a supporter ("support" it), unless e tabled or previously supported it; * Become an objector ("object to" it), unless e previously objected to it; * Cease to be a supporter or objector ("withdraw" support/objection). An intent is ripe if was tabled within the past 14 days, the Speaker hasn't objected to it in the past 48 hours, and its conditions, if any, are met. An intent is mature if it was tabled at least 4 days ago and nobody withdrew objections from it in the past 24 hours. A rule purporting to allow a person to perform a tabled action allows em to do so by announcement, if, considering only intents for that action/method combination: * With N Support: e is a sponsor or supporter of a ripe intent with at least N supporters. * Without N Objections: e is a sponsor of a mature ripe intent with less than N objectors. * With N Agoran Consent: e is a sponsor or supporter of a mature ripe intent with supporters greater than N times its objectors (e SHOULD list supporters and objectors). * With T notice: e is the sponsor of a ripe intent created at least T ago. Repeal Rule 2595 (Performing a Dependent Action). Amend Rule 2481 (Festival Restrictions) by replacing: 1. Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, non-Festive players are not eligible to support a dependent action; with: 1. Rules to the contrary notwithstanding, non-Festive players CANNOT support/be a supporter for tabled action intents; If the effects of a proposal authored by R. Lee have amended Rule 2124 in the previous 14 days, then amend Rule 2124 by deleting: "on eir own behalf," [On this final clause: this proposal is meant to keep all actual mechanics of dep. actions unchanged. I didn't want to take a particular position on whether you can act-on-behalf of someone to support/object to an intent. Unfortunately, it's unclear what the current rules allow. By clarifying in either direction, I'm taking a side. But R. Lee has submitted a proposal called "Allow acting on behalf to support or object". The clause above ensures that if R. Lee's proposal is adopted, the act-on-behalf functionality stays in the rewrite as per the will of the voters.] //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////