RESOLUTION OF PROPOSALS 8215A-8234A =================================== THIS IS AN AUTOMATICALLY GENERATED REPORT. SOME INFORMATION MAY DIFFER FROM THE HISTORICAL REPORT. THE ASSESSMENT SENT TO THE PUBLIC FORUM IS THE DEFINITIVE SOURCE OF HISTORICAL INFORMATION. The official historical report is located at https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2019-September/013133.html ID Title Result --------------------------------------------- 8215 recusal simplification ADOPTED 8216 NO MORE APATHY REJECTED 8217 penance as a service ADOPTED 8218 No, you didn't publish that REJECTED 8221 Usage de-capitalization ADOPTED 8222 Fixing Summary Judgement (v2) ADOPTED 8223 No secret contracts REJECTED 8224 Remove Inactive Sods! REJECTED 8227 Fresh start v2 REJECTED 8228 Active Officers ADOPTED 8229 freeing up space ADOPTED 8230 Close the wormhole ADOPTED 8231 Three-dimensional space v1.1 REJECTED 8232 Increased transparency v1.1 ADOPTED 8233 Duties REJECTED 8234 auto-balance ADOPTED I hereby resolve the Agoran decisions to adopt the below proposals. The quorum for all below decisions was 4. VOTING STRENGTHS ================ Strength is 3 unless otherwise noted. !: player has voting strength 1 $: player has voting strength 4 PROPOSALS ========= PROPOSAL 8215 (recusal simplification) AUTHOR: G. FOR (7): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate, Trigon AGAINST (0): PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 22/0 (AI=1.7) POPULARITY: 1.000 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8216 (NO MORE APATHY) AUTHOR: R. Lee FOR (0): AGAINST (6): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate PRESENT (1): Trigon BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 0/19 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.857 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8217 (penance as a service) AUTHOR: G. FOR (5): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Kate AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): Janet, Trigon BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 16/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.714 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Aris: Endorsement of G. Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Kate: Endorsement of G. ] PROPOSAL 8218 (No, you didn't publish that) AUTHOR: Janet FOR (1): Trigon AGAINST (6): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 3/19 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.714 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet G.: Endorsement of Aris Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Kate: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8221 (Usage de-capitalization) AUTHOR: Janet FOR (4): Aris, G.$, Janet, Trigon AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Falsifian, Jacob Arduino, Kate BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 13/0 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.571 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8222 (Fixing Summary Judgement (v2)) AUTHOR: Janet FOR (6): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate AGAINST (0): PRESENT (1): Trigon BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 19/0 (AI=2.0) POPULARITY: 0.857 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Aris: Endorsement of Janet Falsifian: Endorsement of Janet Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Kate: Endorsement of Janet ] PROPOSAL 8223 (No secret contracts) AUTHOR: R. Lee FOR (1): Trigon AGAINST (6): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 3/19 (AI=2.5) POPULARITY: -0.714 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8224 (Remove Inactive Sods!) AUTHOR: R. Lee FOR (0): AGAINST (5): Aris, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate PRESENT (2): Falsifian, Trigon BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 0/16 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.714 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8227 (Fresh start v2) AUTHOR: Falsifian FOR (1): Trigon AGAINST (6): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 3/19 (AI=3.1) POPULARITY: -0.714 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Janet: Endorsement of Falsifian ] PROPOSAL 8228 (Active Officers) AUTHOR: G. FOR (5): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Janet, Trigon AGAINST (0): PRESENT (2): Jacob Arduino, Kate BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 16/0 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.714 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of G. Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8229 (freeing up space) AUTHOR: G. FOR (4): Aris, G.$, Janet, Trigon AGAINST (0): PRESENT (3): Falsifian, Jacob Arduino, Kate BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 13/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.571 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Trigon: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published ] PROPOSAL 8230 (Close the wormhole) AUTHOR: Murphy FOR (4): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Janet AGAINST (1): Trigon PRESENT (2): Jacob Arduino, Kate BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 13/3 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 0.429 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Aris: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Falsifian: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Janet: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Kate: Endorsement of non-voter Murphy: Inextricable ] PROPOSAL 8231 (Three-dimensional space v1.1) AUTHOR: Murphy FOR (0): AGAINST (3): Falsifian, Janet, Trigon PRESENT (4): Aris, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Kate BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 0/9 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: -0.429 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Aris: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Kate: Endorsement of non-voter Murphy: Inextricable ] PROPOSAL 8232 (Increased transparency v1.1) AUTHOR: Murphy FOR (4): Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate, Trigon AGAINST (1): G.$ PRESENT (2): Aris, Falsifian BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 12/4 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: 0.429 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Falsifian: Endorsement of non-voter Murphy: Inextricable Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8233 (Duties) AUTHOR: Murphy FOR (0): AGAINST (6): Aris, Falsifian, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate, Trigon PRESENT (1): G.$ BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 0/18 (AI=3.0) POPULARITY: -0.857 OUTCOME: REJECTED [ Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate ] PROPOSAL 8234 (auto-balance) AUTHOR: G. FOR (7): Aris, Falsifian, G.$, Jacob Arduino, Janet, Kate, Trigon AGAINST (0): PRESENT (0): BALLOTS: 7 AI (F/A): 22/0 (AI=1.0) POPULARITY: 1.000 OUTCOME: ADOPTED [ Aris: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Falsifian: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published Jacob Arduino: Endorsement of Kate Kate: Endorsement of G. Trigon: Conditional resolved: no Notice of Veto was published ] The full text of each ADOPTED proposal is included below: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8215 Title: recusal simplification Adoption index: 1.7 Author: G. Co-authors: Amend Rule 591 (Delivering Judgements) by deleting the following text: If e does not, the Arbitor CAN remove em from being the judge of that case by announcement, and SHALL do so in a timely fashion after the time limit expires, unless the judge assigns a valid judgement in the mean time. Amend Rule 2492 (Recusal) to read in full: A judge CAN recuse emself from a CFJ e is assigned to, by announcement. The Arbitor CAN recuse a judge from a case by announcement, if that judge has violated a time limit for judging the case and has not judged it in the mean time; the Arbitor SHALL do so in a timely fashion after the time limit expires, if able. If a judge is recused from a case 4+ days after being assigned to it, e SHOULD NOT be assigned as a judge until e has apologised and or reasonably explained eir actions. [ - General rewording goes from 12 to 9 lines of text; net -3 lines in the ruleset. - It was weird that recusing oneself from a CFJ made one ineligible to judge for a week, but being recused for lateness didn't. There are also honorable reasons to self-recuse (e.g. self-interest in the case). Changed this to the idea of "if you're recused in any way after being assigned 4+ days, let us know why, before getting another case", and only governed by a SHOULD. It's as much about helping the Arbitor figure out if the recused are still interested in judging. ] ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8217 Title: penance as a service Adoption index: 2.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Amend Rule 2555 (Blots) by replacing: If a player has neither gained blots nor expunged any blots from emself in the current Agoran week, e CAN expunge 1 blot from emself by announcement. with: If a person (the penitent) has neither gained blots nor had more than 2 blots expunged from emself in the current Agoran week, then any player (the confessor) who has not expunged any blots in the current Agoran week CAN expunge 1 blot from the penitent, by announcement. [Inspired because I wanted to help out Kenyon]. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8221 Title: Usage de-capitalization Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: Aris Amend Rule 2574 by replacing all instances of the text "with Notice" with the text "with notice". Amend Rule 2594 by replacing the text "With 2 Days Notice" with the text "with 2 days notice". Amend Rule 1607 by replacing the text "Without 3 Objections" with the text "without 3 objections". Amend Rule 991 by replacing the text "Without 3 Objections" with the text "without 3 objections". Amend Rule 2415 by replacing the text "Without Objection" with the text "without objection". Amend Rule 2575 by replacing the text "Without Objection" with the text "without objection". Amend Rule 2495 by replacing the text "Without 3 Objections" with the text "without 3 objections". Amend Rule 1006 by replacing the text "With 3 Support" with the text "with 3 support". Amend Rule 2154 by replacing the text "With 2 Support" with the text "With 2 support". Amend Rule 911 by replacing the text "with 2 Support" with the text "with 2 support". Amend Rule 2488 by replacing the text "with 4 Support" with the text "with 4 support". Amend Rule 103 by replacing the text "with Support" with the text "with support". Amend Rule 2493 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2573 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2585 by replacing the text "with Agoran Consent" with the text "with Agoran consent". Amend Rule 649 by replacing the text "With 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2415 by replacing the text "with Agoran Consent" with the text "with Agoran consent". Amend Rule 1367 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2581 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2582 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2463 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". Amend Rule 2566 by replacing the text "with 2 Agoran Consent" with the text "with 2 Agoran consent". ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8222 Title: Fixing Summary Judgement (v2) Adoption index: 2.0 Author: Janet Co-authors: If Proposal 8203 has never taken effect, this proposal applies the effects specified by Proposal 8203. Amend Rule 2531 as follows: Amend the list item beginning "it attempts to levy a fine (i) by summary judgement" to read: it attempts to levy a fine based upon the investigation of of a Finger that had been Pointed more than 14 days after the action constituting the reason for the fine; Amend the list item beginning "it attempts to levy a fine on a player for failing to take an action" to read: it attempts to levy a fine on a player for failing to take an action within the time period set by the Rules and that time period had expired more than 14 days prior to the Pointed Finger, if the fine is imposed based on an investigation of such Finger; ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8228 Title: Active Officers Adoption index: 3.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Janet Amend Rule 2160 (Deputisation) by replacing: A player (the deputy) with: An player acting on eir own behalf (the deputy) Amend Rule 2472/2 (Office Incompatibilities) by inserting this paragraph: A zombie who holds one or more offices is Overpowered. after the paragraph beginning: A player is Overpowered if e holds two offices which are incompatible with each other. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8229 Title: freeing up space Adoption index: 1.0 Author: G. Co-authors: [The universe is imploding! Can any pro-spaaace heroes rush to the rescue and propose fixes in time to convince players to keep it???] Repeal the following rules in this order: Rule 2588 (Sectors) Rule 2589 (Galaxy Maintenance) Rule 2590 (The Astronomor) Rule 2591 (Spaceships) Rule 2592 (Spaceship Energy) Rule 2593 (Space Battles) Rule 2594 (Fame) ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8230 Title: Close the wormhole Adoption index: 1.0 Author: Murphy Co-authors: Amend Rule 2591 (Spaceships) by replacing this text: Spaceships are a class of fixed asset, with this text: Spaceships are a class of indestructible fixed asset, Set each player's Fame to 0. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8232 Title: Increased transparency v1.1 Adoption index: 3.0 Author: Murphy Co-authors: Janet, Kate Amend Rule 2438 (Ribbons) by replacing the sections for the relevant types of ribbons with the following sections: Green (G): While a person holds an elected office, has done so continuously for the past 30 days, and has not failed to perform any duties of that office within the appropriate time limits during those 30 days, that person qualifies for a Green Ribbon. Magenta (M): When, during Agora's Birthday, a person publicly acknowledges it, that person earns a Magenta Ribbon. Transparent (T): A person qualifies for a Transparent Ribbon while the number of other types of Ribbon that that person qualifies for, earns, and/or was awarded within the previous 7 days is at least 5. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8234 Title: auto-balance Adoption index: 1.0 Author: G. Co-authors: Janet Repeal Rule 2511 (Karmic Balance). Append the following paragraph to Rule 2510 (Such is Karma): At the beginning of each quarter, the Karma of every Unregistered person is halved (rounding towards 0), then the Karma of Agora is set such that the sum of all Karma values in the game equals 0. //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////